
Before most people call a lawyer, they read what other clients have said. Reviews on Google, Avvo, Yelp and other sites shape whether your firm gets the call, and the way you respond to those reviews is read just as closely. A thoughtful reply can reassure a future client. A defensive one can cost you cases, and in the worst situations, create a problem with your state bar.
This post covers the high-level principles that matter most when your firm responds to online reviews, whether the review is glowing or painful.
Why Your Responses Matter
Your replies aren’t really written for the person who left the review. They’re written for everyone who reads it later. Prospective clients use your responses to judge:
- Whether you’re professional under pressure.
- Whether you care about the people you represent.
- Whether your firm is active and responsive.
- Whether the negative reviews they see tell the whole story.
Responding consistently also signals to Google that your Business Profile is active, which supports how your firm shows up in local search.
The Rule That Comes First: Confidentiality
Lawyers face a constraint most businesses don’t. Your duty of confidentiality doesn’t disappear because a former client posted something public, or something unfair. The American Bar Association addressed this directly in Formal Opinion 496, which concludes that a negative online review alone doesn’t permit a lawyer to reveal confidential information in a reply.
In practice, that means your public response should never:
- Confirm that the reviewer was your client.
- Mention any detail of their matter, outcome or fees.
- Correct their account with facts you learned through the representation.
Rules vary by state, so check your state bar’s guidance. The safest approach almost everywhere is a reply that shows professionalism without revealing anything about the person or the case.
How to Respond to Positive Reviews
Thank people, and keep it short. A sincere, brief reply shows future clients that you value the people you work with. A few cautions:
- Keep the reply general. Even a happy client may not want you to confirm publicly that you handled their matter.
- Don’t repeat case details the reviewer shared.
- Vary your wording so replies don’t read like a copy-and-paste template.
How to Respond to Negative Reviews
A negative review is uncomfortable, but it’s also a chance to show prospective clients how you handle problems. Before you reply:
- Wait until you can respond calmly. A reply written in frustration rarely helps.
- Decide whether a public reply is needed at all. Sometimes a short, neutral response is enough, and sometimes no response is the better choice.
- If you want to resolve the concern, invite the person to contact your office directly rather than discussing it in public.
A strong reply is brief, professional and free of anything confidential. Something like: “We take all feedback seriously. Our professional obligations prevent us from discussing any matter publicly, but we welcome the chance to talk directly. Please call our office.” That tells readers you’re responsive without saying anything about the reviewer.
When a Review Isn’t Real
Sometimes a review comes from someone who was never your client, a competitor, or an opposing party in a case. Most review platforms have a process for reporting reviews that violate their policies. Report it through the platform, and avoid accusing the reviewer publicly. If you do respond, a short, neutral reply is usually safer than an argument.
Build a Steady Flow of Reviews
The best defense against a single bad review is a steady stream of genuine ones. Many satisfied clients are happy to leave a review if you ask at the right time and make it easy. A few guidelines:
- Ask at a natural point, such as when a matter wraps up well.
- Send a direct link so leaving a review takes less than a minute.
- Don’t offer anything of value in exchange for a review, and don’t write or edit reviews for clients.
- Check your state’s rules on soliciting testimonials and how reviews can be used in your advertising.
Make It Part of Your Routine
Reviews work best when someone at your firm owns them. Decide who monitors new reviews, how quickly replies go out, and who approves responses to anything negative. A simple, consistent process keeps your replies professional and keeps review requests from falling through the cracks.
Want Help Managing Your Firm’s Reviews?
Legal CMO NOW helps solo and small law firms build their reputation online, from Google Business Profile to review requests that keep working in the background. Book a free 30-minute consultation and we’ll talk through what future clients see when they look you up.
Or reach us directly: 572-275-0958 · cmo@legalcmonow.com